Real Versus False Empathy: Which One Are You Reflecting?

Understanding Real Versus False Empathy: Which One Are You Reflecting?

What Is Real Empathy?

Empathy is the ability to understand and share the feelings of another person. When it comes to children, real empathy goes beyond just saying the right things—it’s about truly connecting with their emotions and validating their experiences.

Real empathy means:

• Listening without judgment
• Acknowledging their emotions instead of dismissing them
• Responding with genuine care and support
• Helping them navigate their feelings instead of fixing things for them

When a child expresses sadness, frustration, or fear, real empathy is being present with them instead of offering quick reassurances like, “You’ll be fine” or “It’s not a big deal.”

What Is False Empathy?

False empathy, on the other hand, is when an adult appears to be empathetic but is actually minimizing or dismissing the child’s emotions. It often comes from good intentions, but it ultimately invalidates the child’s experience.

Examples of false empathy:

• “Don’t worry, it’s nothing.” → Dismissing their feelings
• “I know exactly how you feel.” → Assuming their experience is the same as yours
• “It’s okay, stop crying.” → Encouraging suppression instead of processing emotions
• Overindulging and rescuing → Giving in to every demand to avoid discomfort

False empathy can also appear when adults say the right words but lack true emotional presence. Children are incredibly perceptive—they can sense when an adult’s words don’t match their tone, body language, or true feelings.

What Research Says About Real vs. False Empathy

Studies in child psychology and neuroscience have proven the deep impact of real empathy on a child’s emotional intelligence development. Research shows that:

• Children develop stronger emotional intelligence when they experience genuine empathy from caregivers.
• Brain scans reveal that real empathy strengthens neural pathways related to emotional regulation and resilience.
• Children who receive real empathy are more likely to develop trust, confidence, and problem-solving skills.
• False empathy, on the other hand, can create confusion and emotional insecurity. When children sense inauthenticity, they may struggle with self-expression and develop difficulties in recognizing and managing emotions.

According to Dr. Daniel Siegel, a leading researcher in child psychology, authentic emotional attunement helps children feel seen, safe, and understood, which directly influences their self-worth and mental well-being.

Children Know the Difference: Real vs. False Empathy

One of the biggest mistakes adults make is assuming children don’t notice the difference between real and false empathy.

But the truth is—they do.

Children are highly intuitive. They pick up on tone, facial expressions, and body language even before they fully understand words. When an adult offers false empathy, a child may:

• Feel disconnected and unheard
• Stop expressing emotions openly
• Develop distrust toward adults
• Struggle with self-worth and validation
• Eventually reflect back false empathy, becoming disengaged and disinterested learners
• Experience distress due to emotional inconsistency

When a child senses real empathy, they:

• Feel safe and understood
• Develop healthy emotional regulation
• Learn to trust themselves and others
• Build resilience and confidence

How to Show Real Empathy to Children

Real empathy isn’t complicated, but it does require awareness and intention. Here are some ways to cultivate true empathy with children:

1. Truly Listen

Instead of rushing to solve their problem or change their emotion, simply be present.

• Maintain eye contact
• Use open body language
• Allow them to fully express themselves without interruption

2. Validate Their Feelings

Instead of dismissing or minimizing their emotions, acknowledge them:

• “I see that you’re really upset about this.”
• “That must have been really frustrating for you.”
• “It’s okay to feel sad. I’m here for you.”

3. Ask, Don’t Assume

Every child processes emotions differently. Instead of saying, “I know how you feel,” try:

• “Would you like to tell me more about what happened?”
• “What do you think would help you feel better right now?”
• “Do you want a hug, or do you need some space?”

4. Teach Emotional Awareness

Help children identify and name their emotions so they feel more in control:

• “I see you’re frustrated. Let’s talk about what’s making you feel this way.”
• “It’s okay to feel nervous before a big test. What’s one thing that might help?”

5. Model Real Empathy in Everyday Life

Children learn more from what we do than what we say. Show them real empathy in action:

• Apologize when you make a mistake: “I’m sorry I got impatient. I understand that must have been frustrating for you.”
• Express your own emotions: “I’m feeling a little tired today, but I know I’ll feel better after some rest.”
• Be compassionate to others: “That person looks upset—maybe we can ask if they need help.”

Additional Considerations for Parents of Non-Verbal Children

All approaches will and can remain the same, but here are some additional strategies for parents of non-verbal children:

1. Observe Non-Verbal Cues

Non-verbal children communicate through facial expressions, gestures, body language, and even changes in breathing patterns. Pay attention to these cues to understand their emotions.

2. Use Visual Supports

Visual aids such as picture cards, communication boards, or sign language can help non-verbal children express their feelings and needs effectively.

3. Respond with Presence and Patience

Acknowledge their emotions even if they can’t verbalize them. Saying, “I see that you’re upset, and I’m here to help,” while offering comforting gestures, can be reassuring.

4. Engage in Sensory-Based Communication

Some children respond better to touch, movement, or sensory-friendly interactions. A gentle squeeze of the hand or a calming activity can help convey empathy.

5. Model Emotional Expressions

Help them associate emotions with real-life situations by modeling expressions and using simple language. For example, saying “I feel happy when we play together” while smiling reinforces emotional understanding.

By adapting these approaches, parents of non-verbal children can ensure their child still experiences real empathy, fostering connection and emotional security.

Are You Getting It Right? Look at Your Child’s Feedback

Children will always tell us—through their behavior, emotions, and interactions—if we are getting it right or wrong.

If a child is:

• Expressing emotions openly and comfortably
• Engaging and showing interest in learning
• Developing healthy relationships
• Trusting themselves and their environment

Then real empathy is being reflected.

However, if a child is:

• Becoming emotionally withdrawn
• Reacting with indifference to others’ feelings
• Struggling to communicate their needs
• Displaying signs of emotional distress

Then false empathy may be at play.

By paying attention to how children respond to us, we can adjust our approach and ensure that they feel truly heard, supported, and emotionally secure.

Final Thoughts: The Power of Real Empathy

Children thrive when they feel heard, understood, and valued. Real empathy gives them the tools to navigate their emotions, trust themselves, and develop strong relationships. But its impact goes far beyond childhood. The empathy we show our children today shapes the people they will become tomorrow. It influences their relationships, their careers, and their overall well-being. So, let’s make a conscious effort to offer real empathy, not just false comforts. 

Let’s give our children the gift of being truly seen, heard, and valued.

Thank you for taking it onboard